← The record

SomatropinGenotropin and Genotropin Miniquick

Recommended EndocrinologyAuthority Required 💬 consumer voice

Treatment of severe late onset growth hormone deficiency (GHD) in adults. The drug is indicated for replacement therapy in adults with pronounced GHD as diagnosed in dynamic tests.

12
Submissions
8 resub
2006–23
On the record
$15k–75k
ICER range
2 sourced ICERs · 2008–2016
Cost-min
Cost basis

Decisions on record

24 decisions
  • Meeting May 2024 Recommended Late onset growth hormone deficiency no PSD
  • Meeting Sep 2023 Recommended Severe late onset growth hormone deficiency
  • Meeting Sep 2021 Recommended Severe Growth Hormone Deficiency no PSD
  • Meeting May 2020 Noted Severe growth hormone deficiency (GHD) no PSD
  • Meeting Aug 2019 Noted Severe growth hormone deficiency
  • Meeting Mar 2019 Noted Severe growth hormone deficiency
  • Meeting Jul 2018 Recommended Growth disturbance due to insufficient secretion of pituitary growth hormone, or growth disturbance associated with gonadal dysgenesis (Turner syndrome) or chronic renal insufficiency
  • Meeting Jul 2017 Recommended Severe growth hormone deficiency
16 earlier decisions
  • Nov 2016 Recommended Severe growth hormone deficiency
  • Nov 2016 Deferred Severe growth hormone deficiency
  • Mar 2016 Recommended Growth hormone deficiency, Turner syndrome, Prader-Willi syndrome and chronic renal insufficiency
  • Mar 2014 Recommended Omnitrope® Sandoz Pty Ltd Human Growth Hormone deficiencies To request listing of an additional brand of somatropin 45 international units on the Section 100 (Human Growth Hormone Program). no PSD
  • Nov 2011 Recommended Growth hormone deficiency no PSD
  • Jul 2011 Recommended Growth hormone
  • Jul 2011 Not recommended Growth hormone
  • Mar 2011 Recommended Growth hormone deficiency no PSD
  • Nov 2010 Recommended Growth hormone no PSD
  • Mar 2010 Recommended Growth hormone no PSD
  • Mar 2008 Recommended Prader-Willi Syndrome
  • Mar 2008 Recommended Growth Hormone
  • Mar 2008 Recommended Growth Hormone
  • Mar 2008 Recommended Growth Hormone
  • Nov 2006 Not recommended Treatment of short stature due to decreased or failed secretion of pituitary growth hormone. Treatment of adults with severe growth hormone deficiency as diagnosed in the insulin tolerance test for growth hormone deficiency and defined by peak growth hormone concentrations of less than 2.5 nanogram/
  • Sep 2001 Recommended Human growth hormone. no PSD

Access path

12 submissions · public record
  1. TGA registered · Genotropin and Genotropin Miniquick

    TGA label narrower than the PBS population

  2. Nov 2006
    Not recommended

    Long-term benefit highly uncertain; lack of evidence that body fat reduction persists after cessation of therapy at age…

  3. Nov 2006
    Not recommended

    Uncertain long-term benefit after cessation of therapy at age 18, absence of modelled health-outcome analysis…

  4. ↻ resubmitted
    Mar 2008
    Recommended · restricted
  5. Jul 2011
    Not recommended

    uncertain quality of life benefit (meta-analyses of QoL instruments did not demonstrate clinically significant…

  6. ↻ resubmitted
    Mar 2016
    Recommended

    Comparator changed: standard care (SC), which consists of regular monitoring by an…

  7. Nov 2016
    Deferred

    Comparator changed: Genotropin MiniQuick 0.6 mg → standard care

  8. Nov 2016
    Recommended · restricted

    Comparator changed: Genotropin MiniQuick 0.6 mg → standard care

  9. Jul 2017
    Recommended · restricted

    Evidence: Cost-minimisation → Single-arm

  10. Jul 2018
    Recommended · restricted

    Evidence: Single-arm → Cost-minimisation

  11. Mar 2019
    Recommended · restricted

    Listing: Restricted → Authority Required

  12. Aug 2019
    Noted
  13. Sep 2023
    Recommended · restricted

    Evidence: Other → Cost-minimisation

  14. PBS listing · Authority Required
RecommendedDeferredNot recommended

From the public summary

Verbatim · PSD text · may span indications
PBAC outcome
6.1 The PBAC recommended the listing of somatropin solution for injection 6 mg (18 i.u.) in 1.03 mL and 12 mg (36 i.u.) in 1.5 mL (Saizen) for the treatment of severe late onset GHD, on the basis that it should be available only under special arrangements under Section 100 (Growth Hormone Program), and under the same circumstances as somatropin products currently PBS-listed for this indication.PSD · Sep 2023
6.2 In making its recommendation, the PBAC recalled its previous recommendation in July 2017 to list somatropin for the treatment of severe late onset GHD and noted that three brands of somatropin are currently PBS-listed as a result of this recommendation. The PBAC further noted that its July 2017 recommendation in relation to the forms of somatropin where a listing for severe late onset GHD had not been implemented has now been rescinded.PSD · Sep 2023
Economic analysis
5.4 The submission noted that, since the July 2017 recommendation and listing of somatropin products for adult patients with severe GHD, the approved ex- manufacturer price (AEMP) of somatropin products has decreased by 24.79% due to a catch-up statutory price reduction on 1 April 2023. 5PSD · Sep 2023
5.5 The submission proposed an AEMP for Saizen 6 mg and 12 mg to match those of Norditropin FlexPro, NutropinAq and Genotropin GoQuick on a per milligram basis, that would apply to both paediatric and adult indications. The submission stated this was a 3.1% reduction in the current AEMP of Saizen 6 mg and 12 mg (see Table 1).PSD · Sep 2023
Clinical claim
6.11 The November 2016 resubmission claimed that somatropin is superior in terms of comparative effectiveness with respect to QoL and noninferior in terms of comparative safety over standard care. In the absence of comparative data, the PBAC considered that the comparative effectiveness over standard care, in terms of QoL improvement, was difficult to quantify and was likely overestimated.PSD · Jul 2017
6.12 The minor resubmission claimed superior comparative effectiveness of somatropin compared with BSC. Specifically, it claimed that, “GH replacement improves body composition, cardiorespiratory function, metabolic status and QoL in adult patients with severe GHD.PSD · Jul 2017
Consumer comments
6.2 The PBAC noted that no consumer comments were received for this item. However, the PBAC recalled that for its November 2016 consideration of somatropin for adults with GHD it received substantial input from individuals (68), health care professionals (2) and organisations (2) via the Consumer Comments facility on the PBS website.PSD · Jul 2017
Financial management – risk sharing
6.59 The resubmission did not propose any Risk Sharing Arrangement, although the PBAC noted that such proposals would likely be beyond the scope of a submission not lodged by a sponsor.PSD · Nov 2016

Cost-effectiveness

2 sourced ICERs · 2008–2016

Cost-minimisation analysis; no ICER calculated as Saizen is not expected to provide substantial and clinically relevant improvement in efficacy or reduction of toxicity over other PBS-listed somatropin products for this indication.

The PBAC noted that this submission is not eligible for an Independent Review because it received a positive recommendation. PBAC · 2023
ICER uncertain ×4ICER / price too high ×2Economic model disputed ×2Price cut / RSA neededSurrogate endpoint ×2Cost-effectiveness accepted ×5

Decision context

PopulationAdults with severe late onset growth hormone deficiency, diagnosed by dynamic tests with peak GH concentrations less than 2.5 nanogram/mL, who have either childhood-onset GHD (requiring retesting and confirmation) or adult-onset GHD (requiring GHD from hypothalamic or pituitary disease with at least one other hormone deficiency and adequate replacement therapy).

Submission history

12 entries
DecidedOutcomeComparatorICEREvidence
Sep 2023 Recommended · restricted other somatropin products PBS-listed for severe late onset GHD (Genotropin GoQuick, Norditropin FlexPro, NutropinAq) Cost-minimisation · Cost-minimisation
Aug 2019 Noted Other
Mar 2019 Recommended · restricted
Jul 2018 Recommended · restricted Cost-minimisation
Jul 2017 Recommended · restricted standard care / placebo Single-arm · QoL
Nov 2016 Deferred standard care $15k–45k Single-arm · QoL
Nov 2016 Recommended · restricted Cost-minimisation
Mar 2016 Recommended Genotropin MiniQuick 0.6 mg Cost-minimisation · Cost-minimisation
Jul 2011 Not recommended standard care (SC), which consists of regular monitoring by an endocrinologist, medical management of signs and symptoms RCT · QoL, body composition (lean body mass - LBM and fat mass - FM)
Mar 2008 Recommended · restricted placebo $45k–75k RCT · Other
Nov 2006 Not recommended placebo RCT · percent body fat reduction
Nov 2006 Not recommended placebo RCT

Consumer voice

Sep 2023

No consumer comments were received for the July 2017 meeting. However, the PBAC noted that at its November 2016 consideration of somatropin for adults with GHD, it had received substantial input from 68 individuals, 2 health care professionals, and 2 organisations via the Consumer Comments facility on the PBS website. Due to the clinical need and product shortage, consumer comments were not sought

Due to the nature of the clinical need for this product given the shortage, no consumer comments were sought to expedite consideration. Consumer comments · PSD
unmet needaccess barriersclinical shortage

Similar precedents

By decision profile

Regulatory · TGA

Label narrower than PBS population — PBAC restricts to severe adult-onset GHD only; TGA label includes children with GHD, Turner syndrome, and chronic renal insufficiency.