← The record

Oxycodone Hydrochloride And Naloxone Hydrochloride DihydrateARX-Oxycodone/Naloxone

Not recommended Pain

Chronic severe disabling pain not responding to non-narcotic analgesics.

2
Submissions
2010–10
On the record
$15k–105k
ICER range
2 sourced ICERs · 2010
ICER stated
Cost basis

Decision on record

1 decision
  • Meeting Jul 2010 Not recommended Pain relief

Access path

2 submissions · public record
  1. TGA registered · ARX-Oxycodone/Naloxone

    TGA label narrower than the PBS population

  2. Jul 2010
    Not recommended

    uncertain and high cost-effectiveness ratio; inappropriate comparator selection (oxycodone alone rather than oxycodone…

  3. Jul 2010
    Not recommended

    Uncertain and high cost-effectiveness ratio, inappropriate comparator (oxycodone alone rather than oxycodone plus…

RecommendedDeferredNot recommended

Cost-effectiveness

2 sourced ICERs · 2010

Base case ICER $15,000–$45,000 per QALY; respecified base case $45,000–$105,000 per QALY; probabilistic sensitivity analysis produced ICER >$200,000 per QALY.

The PBAC considered that the base case of between $15,000 and $45,000 per QALY gained was highly uncertain given the assumption that individuals who take prophylactic laxatives have the same probability of OIC as those who do not take laxatives and that all complications of OIC will occur. PBAC · 2010
ICER uncertainICER / price too highEconomic model disputed

Decision context

PopulationPatients with moderate to severe chronic pain (cancer and non-cancer), particularly those experiencing opioid-induced constipation.

Why it was knocked back

  • Uncertain and high cost-effectiveness ratio, inappropriate comparator (oxycodone alone rather than oxycodone plus prophylactic laxatives), borderline clinical significance of BFI results, populations in key clinical trials not representative of likely Australian population, inappropriate 1-year time horizon for non-malignant pain, highly uncertain economic model with major flaws in use of proxy measures, underestimated average daily dosage, uncertain uptake rate, uncertain complication estimates based on poor-response clinician survey.

Submission history

2 entries
DecidedOutcomeComparatorICEREvidence
Jul 2010 Not recommended oxycodone plus prophylactic laxatives $45k–105k RCT · Bowel Function Index (BFI)
Jul 2010 Not recommended oxycodone controlled release (with or without prophylactic laxatives) $15k–105k RCT · BFI

Similar precedents

By decision profile

Regulatory · TGA

Label narrower than PBS population — PBAC restricts to chronic severe disabling pain; TGA label includes moderate pain and lacks chronicity/disability requirement.